How Much Hail Damage to Replace Roof

How Much Hail Damage to Replace Roof

How Much Hail Damage to Replace Roof? Generally, hail that is 1 inch in diameter or larger can seriously harm asphalt shingles, often leading to a roof replacement.

When determining how much hail damage is necessary to replace a roof, the key factors are the size of the hail and the type of roofing material. 

Key Takeaways

Key TakeawaysDetails
Identifying Hail DamageLook for visible roof damage like dents and broken shingles, especially after a hailstorm.
Factors Influencing DamageThe size of the hail and the type of roofing material significantly affect the level of damage.
Insurance and Roof ReplacementInsurance coverage is crucial; work with adjusters to assess damage and understand coverage for replacements.
Temporary vs. Long-Term FixesDistinguish between temporary fixes (like tarping) and long-term solutions (like full replacement).
Preventing Hail DamageUse hail-resistant materials like EPDM rubber, Euroshield® rubber, and metal roofing.
When to Repair or ReplaceDecision based on the extent of damage, age of roof, and professional assessments.
Advancements in Roofing MaterialsModern technologies offer enhanced hail-resistant roofing options.

Understanding Hail Damage

Hail can cause significant damage to roofs, varying based on the hail’s size and the roofing material’s durability. Here’s what you need to know:

Size Matters

  • Small vs. Large Hail: Smaller hailstones might not cause noticeable damage, but larger ones, especially those 1 inch in diameter or more, can create dents and cracks in shingles.
  • Type of Shingles: Different materials have varying resistance to hail. For example, asphalt shingles are more susceptible to damage than metal roofing.

Spotting the Damage

  • Visual Signs: Look for dents, cracks, or missing granules on asphalt shingles. These signs indicate that the shingles’ integrity has been compromised.
  • Hidden Damage: Sometimes, hail damage isn’t immediately visible. It can weaken the shingles over time, leading to leaks and further deterioration.

Preventing Hail Damage: Tips and Strategies

Minimizing the risk of hail damage to your roof involves proactive measures and informed choices in materials and maintenance. Here are some key strategies:

Choose Hail-Resistant Roofing Materials

  • Opt for materials known for their resilience to hail, like class 4-rated asphalt shingles, metal roofing, or modified rubber shingles. These materials can better withstand the impact of hailstones.

Regular Roof Inspections

  • Schedule annual or bi-annual professional inspections. These can identify and address minor issues before they escalate following a hailstorm.

Keep Trees Trimmed

  • Regularly trim overhanging tree branches. This reduces the risk of branches falling on the roof during a hailstorm and causing additional damage.

Install Protective Barriers

  • Consider installing hail guards or shields, especially for skylights and roof vents, vulnerable to hail damage.

Gutter Maintenance

  • Keep gutters and downspouts clean and well-maintained. This ensures proper drainage during hailstorms, preventing water accumulation and potential damage.

Implementing these steps can significantly reduce the risk of severe hail damage to your roof, ensuring its longevity and structural integrity.

Role of Insurance in Roof Replacement

Insurance companies play a significant role in roof replacements due to hail damage. Here’s what you should consider:

Insurance Adjusters’ Recommendations

  • Inspections: An insurance adjuster will inspect your roof to determine the extent of the damage.
  • Criteria for Replacement: If the damage meets the insurance company’s criteria, they may cover the cost of a full roof replacement.

Filing a Claim

Hail Damage: Temporary Fixes vs. Long-Term Solutions

When dealing with hail damage, it’s important to distinguish between temporary fixes and long-term solutions to ensure the roof’s integrity and longevity. Here’s a quick guide:

Temporary Fixes

  • Emergency Tarping: Following hail damage, applying a waterproof tarp can provide immediate protection against water intrusion until repairs are made.
  • Minor Patching: Small cracks or holes can be temporarily patched to prevent further damage.

Long-Term Solutions

  • Full Roof Replacement: If hail damage is extensive, replacing the entire roof is often the most effective long-term solution.
  • Upgrading Materials: When replacing, consider upgrading to more hail-resistant materials to prevent future damage.
  • Professional Repairs: For less severe damage, professional repairs can restore the roof’s integrity, addressing all compromised areas.

Understanding the difference between these approaches helps make informed decisions after a hail event, balancing immediate needs with long-term roof health.

Hail Damage to roof during storm

Roof Hail Damage: Repair vs. Replace

Deciding whether to repair or replace a roof depends on the damage’s extent:

Professional Inspection

  • Expert Evaluation: A roofing professional can assess the damage and recommend whether to repair or replace the roof.
  • Cost-Benefit Analysis: Sometimes, repairing the damaged area might be more cost-effective, but if the damage is extensive, a replacement could be the better long-term solution.

Consider the Roof’s Age

  • Older Roofs: Replacing your roof might be more sensible than repairing it if it is near its lifespan.
  • Warranty and Lifespan: Check if the existing roof is still under warranty and consider its remaining lifespan.

Latest Roofing Technologies Resistant to Hail Damage

Advancements in roofing technology have led to materials that offer enhanced resistance to hail damage. Here are some top choices:

EPDM Rubber Roofing

  • Impact Resilience: EPDM roofs resist hail because they absorb and disperse energy, much like a cushion.

Euroshield® Rubber Roofing

  • High Impact Resistance: Designed to return to its original shape after impact, similar to a car tire over a pothole, Euroshield® can withstand hail up to 2 inches in diameter and comes with a warranty.

Metal Roofing

  • Durability and Strength: Metal roofs, especially those made from 26 gauge steel panels or thicker, are highly hail-resistant. They prevent punctures and maintain strong seams, offering robust protection during hailstorms.

These modern roofing solutions provide homeowners with durable, long-lasting options for protecting their homes against hail and other extreme weather conditions.


The decision to replace a roof due to hail damage hinges on several factors, including the hail’s size, the extent of the damage, and the roofing material’s type. Insurance coverage also plays a crucial role. 

Remember, the first step in addressing hail damage is scheduling a professional inspection to accurately assess the damage and decide the best course of action. Y

our safety and the longevity of your roof are paramount.

Scroll to Top